Inamorata (Chance) - Discussion Questions

Discussion Questions
1. Odile’s gift is to inspire a great work of art, but the cost is that the artist never creates again. Do you think, as she does, that such a price is worth it? Is there any work of art or literature that you feel would be worth such a sacrifice? Do you think, as Odile does, that art requires sacrifice?

2. What do you think of the role of art in our lives? Do you agree, as the characters in the book do, that it can give life meaning and, as Odile says, give mankind a reason to strive, something that counters death and suffering? How important do you think art is?

3. Nicholas thinks of himself as a savior, even though his wish to save men from Odile has backfired more than once—leading men to commit suicide in some cases. Do you think he’s right? Do you believe, as Nicholas does, that their deaths are a mercy compared to what will happen to them in Odile’s hands?

4. Odile asks Joseph where his “vision” comes from, and he answers that it doesn’t matter. Do you agree? Do you think where talent or inspiration comes from is important? Does knowing the source of an artist’s inspiration change the way you view his work?

5. Sophie’s love for her brother and his for her was tempered and changed by abuse. What do you think of the their relationship? Do you think it wrong or immoral, particularly given what forged it?

6. Do you think the inspiration Joseph takes from his sister is tainted by their relationship? Or does the depth of his talent redeem it and make it all right—or even necessary?

7. In the book we discover that Joseph’s writing of an anonymous letter to Edward Roberts’ father led to Edward’s suicide. Do you think Joseph’s writing of this letter was justified, given what Edward did to them?

8. Do you believe Sophie and Joseph cripple each other? Do you think they live “half a life,” as Odile believes? Or do you think, as Sophie does, that theirs are lives “doubly lived?”

9. What do you think of the reasons that motivate Nicholas and Odile—his need to “matter” and hers to be recognized? Do you think those worthy or admirable motivations?

10. If you had been offered the gift that Madeleine offered Odile, would you take it?
(Questions from the author's website.)

top of page (summary)