What Matters Most (Rice) - Book Reviews

Book Reviews
True love never dies-but it may need the helping hand of the Virgin Mary and the luck o' the Irish to survive in Rice's latest, effectively a sequel to last year's Sandcastles. Sister Bernadette Ignatius (the former Bernie Sullivan), Mother Superior at the coastal Connecticut Star of the Sea Academy, travels to Dublin with Tom Kelly, the academy's ombudsman, seeking James, the son they gave up over 20 years ago. In a parallel narrative set up in a prologue, young James and Kathleen, raised together as orphans, are devastated when they are forced to separate when Kathleen is 13. While Bernie and Tom look for James (now calling himself Seamus), James searches for Kathleen, who pines for him in a Newport, R.I., mansion, where she is a cook and maid for an atrocious, wealthy family. Rice juices up the predictable plot line with miraculous visions, ghosts, convenient encounters and melodramatic twists of fate-yet the effects are still lukewarm, though there's guilt, redemption and three-hankie moments aplenty for those who stick it out to the end.
Publishers Weekly


An emotionally exhaustive revisit with the two Irish-American families from Sandcastles (2006). This time around, Rice turns her attention to Sister Bernadette (Bernie) Sullivan and Thomas (Tom) Kelly. Long before Sister Bernie took her vows, she and Tom were young lovers. While on a romantic holiday to Ireland connecting with their roots, Bernie and Tom shared a single night of passion. Bernie became pregnant. Tom wanted to keep the baby, but Bernie struggled between her calling to the church and her love for Tom. Ultimately, the baby was given up for adoption. Now, 20-odd years later, Tom and Bernie decide to fly to Dublin to track down their son, Seamus, and introduce themselves as his parents. At the reunion, Seamus wants nothing to do with the family that abandoned him and left him in a crowded orphanage. To make matters more complicated, the disastrous meeting stirs up old passions between Tom and Bernie. Their romantic detente ends and their friendship is irrevocably altered. Tom makes a final effort to win over Seamus before flying back to America. Grudgingly, Seamus accepts Tom's help when Tom offers to use his influence to reunite Seamus with his lost love from the orphanage. With Tom's help, Seamus tracks down his love in America. At this point, the plot spins wildly out of control as the author tosses in one melodramatic, outlandish event after another. Though a few new characters are sprinkled in, it's impossible to care about them. Rice, usually good at bringing to life the Irish landscape, this time falls flat.
Kirkus Reviews